Joseph Sweeney
5 min readDec 16, 2022

--

I used ChatGPT from OpenAI this morning to ask some questions about Decision Education. Here are the actual questions and answers without edits. Questions from me in bold. Answers from the ChatGPT artificial intelligence are in italics.

What is Decision Education?

Decision education is the process of teaching people how to make good decisions. This can involve learning about different decision-making strategies, understanding how to gather and analyze information, and developing critical thinking skills. Decision education can be applied in a variety of contexts, including personal, professional, and academic settings. It is often incorporated into formal education programs, such as business or psychology courses, but it can also be learned informally through experience or self-study. Decision education is important because it helps people make informed, rational, and well-considered choices that can have a positive impact on their lives.

How do estimating and predicting skills impact decision quality?

Estimating and predicting skills can impact decision quality in several ways. First, being able to accurately estimate and predict outcomes can help decision-makers understand the potential consequences of different actions. This can help them weigh the pros and cons of different options and choose the one that is most likely to achieve their desired results.

Second, being able to estimate and predict can help decision-makers identify and mitigate risks. By anticipating potential problems or challenges, they can take steps to prevent them from occurring or minimize their impact.

Third, being able to estimate and predict can help decision-makers allocate resources effectively. By understanding how different actions are likely to affect the allocation of time, money, and other resources, they can make more efficient use of these resources and maximize their return on investment.

Overall, being able to estimate and predict outcomes is an important skill for effective decision-making, as it allows decision-makers to anticipate the consequences of their choices and make informed decisions that are likely to be successful.

What is Expected Value and how is it different than Expected Utility?

Expected value and expected utility are both tools that decision-makers can use to evaluate the potential outcomes of different options and choose the one that is most likely to achieve their desired results. However, they differ in how they consider the likelihood of different outcomes and the value or utility of those outcomes.

Expected value is a measure of the average outcome of a decision, based on the probability of each potential outcome and its value. It is calculated by multiplying the probability of each outcome by its value, and then summing these products. Expected value helps decision-makers understand the overall expected outcome of a decision, based on the likelihood of different outcomes and their values.

Expected utility is a measure of the overall satisfaction or preference that a decision is expected to produce. It is calculated by multiplying the probability of each outcome by the utility or value of that outcome, and then summing these products. Expected utility helps decision-makers understand the overall satisfaction or preference that a decision is likely to produce, based on the likelihood of different outcomes and their utilities.

In general, expected value is more concerned with the monetary value or cost of different outcomes, while expected utility is more concerned with the subjective satisfaction or preference that different outcomes are likely to produce. Both expected value and expected utility can be useful tools for decision-making, depending on the context and the goals of the decision-maker.

Which cognitive biases are the most impactful to human decision-making?

There are many cognitive biases that can impact human decision-making, and the specific biases that are most impactful can vary depending on the context and the individual decision-maker. Some of the cognitive biases that are most commonly cited as having a significant impact on decision-making include:

  1. Anchoring bias: the tendency to rely too heavily on the first piece of information encountered when making a decision.
  2. confirmation bias: the tendency to seek out and interpret information that confirms one’s preexisting beliefs or biases.
  3. framing effect: the tendency to be influenced by the way that information is presented or framed.
  4. sunk cost bias: the tendency to continue investing in a project or course of action because of the resources already invested, even if it is no longer the best option.
  5. availability heuristic: the tendency to make judgments based on information that is readily available or easily remembered, rather than on a more complete set of information.
  6. overconfidence bias: the tendency to be overly confident in one’s own abilities or judgment.
  7. loss aversion: the tendency to place a higher value on avoiding losses than on making gains.

These biases can all influence decision-making in various ways, and can lead to suboptimal or irrational decisions if they are not recognized and addressed.

What are the steps in making a high-quality decision?

There are several steps that can be followed in making a high-quality decision:

  1. Define the problem or decision that needs to be made. Clearly articulate the issue or choice that needs to be addressed.
  2. Gather information. Collect all relevant data and facts that may impact the decision, and consider multiple viewpoints or perspectives.
  3. Identify the options. Generate a list of potential courses of action or solutions to the problem.
  4. Evaluate the options. Consider the pros and cons of each option, and assess their feasibility, likelihood of success, and potential consequences.
  5. Make a choice. Select the option that seems most likely to achieve the desired results, based on the evaluation of the options.
  6. Implement the decision. Take the necessary steps to put the chosen option into action.
  7. Review the decision. After the decision has been implemented, consider whether it was successful and if there are any lessons that can be learned for future decision-making.

By following these steps, decision-makers can make informed, rational, and well-considered choices that are likely to be of high quality.

How would I use Expected Utility to determine whether to buy a house or rent?

To use expected utility to determine whether to buy a house or rent, you would need to consider the following factors:

  1. The probability of different outcomes: What is the likelihood that buying a house will be a good financial decision, compared to renting? You may need to consider factors such as the expected appreciation or depreciation of the property, the likelihood of needing to sell the property in the future, and the potential for unexpected expenses such as repairs or maintenance.
  2. The utility or value of different outcomes: What is the subjective value or utility of owning a home versus renting? This may depend on your personal preferences and priorities, such as your desire for stability, the importance of having a sense of ownership, or the flexibility to make changes to the property.
  3. The costs and benefits of different options: What are the costs and benefits of buying a house versus renting? You may need to consider the initial cost of purchasing a home, as well as ongoing costs such as mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, and maintenance. You may also want to consider the benefits of homeownership, such as the potential for building equity and the ability to customize the property to your own preferences.

To calculate the expected utility of each option, you would need to multiply the probability of each outcome by the utility or value of that outcome, and then sum these products. This will give you an overall measure of the expected utility of each option, which you can use to help decide whether to buy a house or rent.

I don’t know about you, but I am stunned. These responses are far better than I expected. They were produced in seconds. And I think they exceed the quality of answers that most humans would have provided even if they had an hour.

Thoughts?

--

--

Joseph Sweeney

Coffee drinking, general enthusiast. I like to read, cook, sail, and walk in the woods. Dad of teenagers, fortunate in friends, cultivating joy